›› 2003, Vol. 46 ›› Issue (4): 473-478.

• 研究论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟对豚草的联合控制作用

万方浩1*,马骏1,2,郭建英1,游兰韶2   

  • 出版日期:2003-08-20 发布日期:2003-08-20

Integrated control effects of Epiblema strenuana (Lepidoptera: Tortricidae) and Ostrinia orientalis (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae) against ragweed, Ambrosia artemisiifolia (Compositae)

WAN Fang-Hao1*, MA Jun1, 2, GUO Jian-Ying1, YOU Lan-Shao2   

  • Online:2003-08-20 Published:2003-08-20

摘要: 豚草卷蛾Epiblema strenuana是我国引进用于控制豚草Ambrosia artemisiifolia的重要天敌昆虫,苍耳螟Ostrinia orientalis是取食苍耳和豚草的本地种。为了全面评价释放的豚草卷蛾与苍耳螟共存系统中的竞争与控制作用, 作者采用三因子二次正交旋转组合设计的方法,选用豚草的生育期(以主茎近基部直径表示)、豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟虫量为参试因子,分别以豚草的地上部生物量(鲜重)、种子量和株高作为观测目标,分析了豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟对豚草的综合控制效应。结果表明,两种天敌对寄主的生物量、种子量和株高均有明显的抑制作用。各处理组合中,具有最大控制效果的处理组合及其防效分别为:当主茎直径为1.0 cm,单株分别接入豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟63头和8头时,对生物量的控制效果达到94.3%;当主茎直径为1.0 cm,分别接入豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟17头和8头时,对株高的防效为31.7%;当接虫主茎直径为0.7 cm时,单株分别接入豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟40头和5头时,对种子量的防效达到99.3%。而当主茎直径达到2.1cm时,分别接入豚草卷蛾和苍耳螟40头和5头,两种天敌对寄主生物量、种子量和株高的防效仅分别为2.0%、6.1%和-2.4%,抑制效果最低。两种天敌的控制效果随寄主生长和补偿能力的增强而减弱。当寄主处于生长前期(主茎直径小于0.7 cm)时,两种虫量的作用效应大于植株的补偿作用;而长成的寄主植物其补偿效应则大于两种天敌的虫量作用。3种因子间的作用方式相互独立,两种天敌之间不存在明显的竞争干扰现象,属于可利用的有效天敌。综合平均效应表明,寄主的生育期(补偿能力)要大于两种虫量的影响,豚草卷蛾对寄主种子量的影响大于苍耳螟,而苍耳螟对寄主的生物量和植株高度的影响要大于豚草卷蛾。在两种天敌的应用中,为了提高防治效果建议及早在豚草的生长前期释放或扩增天敌种群数量。

关键词: 豚草卷蛾, 苍耳螟, 豚草, 生物防治, 控制效果, 风险评价

Abstract: Epiblema strenuana is a gall inducing lepidopteran that was introduced into China as a biological control agent against ragweed, Ambrosia artemisiifolia. In Linxiang, Hunan Province, E. strenuana feeds on two species of host plants, A. artemisiifolia and Xanthium sibiricum. Ostrinia orientalis, an endemic insect that originally fed on X. sibiricum, is also a borer of A. artemissifolia. In order to assess the ecological impact of E. strenuana where it has been released, especially in locations where it coexists with O. orientalis on A. artemissifolia, a factorial design was used to conduct an experiment in a field cage. The results showed that both E. strenuana and O. orientalis reduced the biomass, seed production and height of the host plant. Biomass was reduced maximally by 94.3% in host plants with a 1.0 cm main stem following inoculation with 63. larvae of E. strenuana and 8 larvae of O. orientalis. Plant height was reduced maximally by 31.7% when 17 larvae of E. strenuana and 8 larvae of O. orientalis were inoculated on plants with a stem diameter of 1.0 cm. Seed production was reduced maximally by 99.3% when 40 larvae of E. strenuana and 5 larvae of O. orientalis were introduced onto a plant with a 0.7 cm main stem diameter. When 40 larvae of E. strenuana and 5 larvae of O. orientalis were inoculated on the host plant with a 2.1 cm main stem diameter, biomass and seed production were reduced by 2.0% and 6.1% respectively, but height increased by 2.4% Control efficiency decreased as the host plant grew because of the increasing capacity for compensatory plant growth. Feeding impact on the biomass, seed production and the height of the host plant, A. artemisiifolia exceeded compensatory growth during the early growth of the plant (main stem < 0.7 cm), but the situation was reversed in the oldest plants. The impact of E. strenuana on seed production was greater than O. orientalis, while the impact of O. orientalis on biomass and plant height was greater than E. strenuana. Furthermore, when these two Insects fed on A. artemisiifolia at the same time, their feeding behavior was independent, and no undesired consequences occurred. In order to utilize these two biocontrol agents efficiently, the insects should be introduced onto the target weeds during the early developmental stages of the host plant.

Key words: Epiblema strenuana, Ostrinia orientalis, Ambrosia artemisiifolia, biological control, control efficiency, risk assessment